Crisp at the edges. Molten in the middle. Unreasonably good. Twin sisters Jeanie & Patti bake every box to order in California and ship it anywhere in America — arriving like it just left the oven.
Nurse Owned
Twin Sister Recipe
Boxes are baked in limited weekly batches — when they're claimed, they're gone until the next drop.
The week's flavors drop on Instagram every Sunday — a rotating special alongside the favorites. The Classic Wish is always on the menu.
Same link every Monday — save it and show up at open. Boxes are limited and go fast; your order is confirmed the moment payment clears.
Baked to order, packed cold, and shipped anywhere in the USA — at your door in 1–2 business days. Free shipping over $100. In Riverside County? Pickup is free; local delivery is available for a small distance-based fee.
Missed the drop? Join the waitlist — leftover boxes and cancellations go to the list first.
A rotating menu, made from scratch in small weekly batches. The Classic Wish is permanent; everything else earns its place week by week. Can't decide? The Baker's Variety box is every flavor at once. Wish accordingly.
Fan Favoritefrom $15
Brown-butter dough, semi-sweet chips, flaky salt. Crisp edge, molten center — the cookie that started it all.
Chocolatefrom $15
Midnight-dark cocoa dough studded with white chocolate. Fudgy, warm, quietly dramatic.
Jeanie's Pick ✦from $15
Golden brown-butter dough crowded with creamy white chips. Jeanie’s own order, every time.
Peanut Butterfrom $15
Two soft peanut butter cookies pressed around a whipped PB filling. Childhood, upgraded.
Best of Bothfrom $15
The Classic, the Cocoa, the White Chip — one box, zero decisions.
Freezer-Readyfrom $22
Our Classic Wish dough, scooped and frozen. Bake from frozen at 350°F — and your kitchen smells like ours.
Bars, brownies, and loaves in small weekly batches — bright, buttery, built for sharing. Or not.
Fudgyfrom $18
Crackle top, molten dark-chocolate center. Best eaten over the box; no crumb left behind.
Loaffrom $14
Fresh lemon juice and zest in a buttery crumb, finished with vanilla glaze. Sunshine, sliced.
Barsfrom $18
Sharp lemon filling on buttery shortbread, under a snowfall of powdered sugar.
Patti bakes bread once a month — long-fermented, hand-shaped, dutch-oven baked. One drop. Limited loaves. Gone until next month.
Handcraftedfrom $7
Long-fermented, hand-shaped, dutch-oven baked. Crackling crust, soft open crumb — bread the slow way.
Signaturefrom $9
Smoky bacon and sharp cheddar folded through an open crumb. Breakfast, grilled cheese, or straight off the cutting board.
One secret flavor a month, revealed only when it lands on your counter. Past drops: jalapeño-cheddar, rosemary-garlic, cranberry-walnut. Trust the twins.
Every signature flavor, shrunk to a single perfect bite and packed 36 to a box. Showers, office spreads, birthdays — one box, everyone happy.
We’re Jeanie and Patti — identical twins, BSN nurses, and the sisters behind Three Wishes. We spend our days caring for patients and our nights preheating ovens.
Three Wishes began with founder Jeanie’s name and a promise we still keep: every box should feel like a wish granted.
Jeanie, founder, runs the cookies and bars — the close-your-eyes-on-the-first-bite kind. Patti, co-founder, is the bread half: one long-fermented sourdough bake a month, made the way bread used to be made.
For years we’ve been the ones baking for our own units and workplaces — hospital teams, office celebrations, organizations like Planned Parenthood. Now the same recipes ship to your door.
Simple storage and warming advice, so every batch tastes the way it did leaving our oven.
Airtight container up to 5 days at room temp, or freeze up to 3 months. Bring back that just-baked hug: 350°F oven for 5–7 min, or microwave 10–15 sec (+20 sec if frozen).
Cookie Dough Sleeves live in the freezer. Preheat to 350°F, arrange pucks on a lined sheet, and bake straight from frozen for warm-from-Jeanie's-kitchen magic.
Orders ship Mondays & Wednesdays in temperature-controlled packaging, 1–2 business day delivery. Contains wheat, milk, eggs, and soy. May contain traces of nuts.
Three Wishes Bakery is not a nut-free, peanut-free, gluten-free, dairy-free, or allergen-free kitchen. Our treats contain or may come into contact with wheat, milk, eggs, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts. Flavors rotate weekly, so please review each product's details before ordering. If you have a severe allergy, our kitchen may not be the safest option for you — and we'd rather tell you that honestly.
Why chilling your dough overnight makes it taste like a bakery, not a batch.
02 · From my kitchenThe 8-minute step that turned my cookies into the ones people ask about.
03 · Pantry noteHow a pinch of Maldon on top makes the chocolate taste like more chocolate.
Tell us three treats you wish were on this menu. Every month Jeanie grants one — the winning wish joins the drop, and the wisher gets it free. Your craving could headline next month’s menu.
Baked to order and shipped nationwide. Cookies by the 6, 12, or 24. Dough by the dozen. Sourdough by the loaf. Free shipping on orders $100+ — small orders welcome, but the box travels smarter full. Three wishes feels like the right place to start.
Place an order → Catering inquiriesTRUSTED BY OUR OWN WORKPLACES ✦ HOSPITAL TEAMS ✦ ORGANIZATIONS LIKE PLANNED PARENTHOOD
Yes — every order is baked to order and shipped anywhere in the USA in temperature-controlled packaging, arriving in 1–2 business days. Free shipping on orders $100+.
Yes — pickup in Riverside County is free. Local delivery is available for a distance-based fee (it's a big county!); we confirm the fee with you before anything is charged.
Patti bakes one secret sourdough flavor each month. You find out what it is when it arrives — that's the fun.
The menu reveals Sundays on Instagram, orders open Mondays, and limited boxes ship Monday & Wednesday. The Classic Wish is always on the menu.
Yes — twin BSN nurses, working shifts and working ovens. Cookie care is literally in our job description.
Make your three wishes below — every month founder Jeanie grants one, adds it to the menu, and sends the winner theirs free.